Skip to content

Frequently asked questions

Best Comment Picker picks random giveaway winners from the comments on a public Instagram post or TikTok video. It's free for posts up to 300 comments, needs no login to Instagram or TikTok, draws winners with cryptographic random numbers and gives every draw a public result page. Below are the questions people ask most.

The draw

How is the winner chosen?

After your entry rules are applied, winners are drawn on our server with cryptographic random numbers: a Fisher-Yates shuffle using crypto.randomInt. Every eligible entry has the same chance, the picker has no way to favor anyone, and the result can't be predicted. The result page shows the method, the rules and the time of the draw.

Can I pick several winners?

Yes. One draw can pick up to 10 winners and up to 5 backup winners. Backups are drawn right after the winners, in order, so if a winner doesn't reply you move to the next backup instead of drawing again. No account can win twice in the same draw.

What happens when someone comments many times?

By default each account counts once, whatever the number of comments, which is what most giveaway rules say. Turn off One entry per account if your rules give an extra entry per comment; the same account still can't win twice in one draw.

Can the account that posted the giveaway win?

No. The post's own account is always left out of the draw, and you can add more accounts to leave out, like your team or brand partners.

Can I draw again if I don't like the winner?

Each draw is final and has its own result page with its time. If a winner doesn't reply, use the backup winners you drew, in order. A new draw is a new result, with its own page.

How do reveals work?

Choose a countdown, a spinning wheel or an instant reveal before you draw. The winners are already decided by the draw; the reveal is only how they appear on screen, which makes it nice to film or screen-record live.

Comments and links

Do I need to log in with Instagram or TikTok?

No. The picker only needs the link to a public post or video. It never asks for your Instagram or TikTok password and never posts anything on your account.

Why does the picker read fewer comments than Instagram shows?

The number under a post also counts comments that were deleted, hidden by filters or restricted, and some replies. Those aren't public, so no picker can read them.

Which links work?

Public Instagram posts and reels (including carousels) and public TikTok videos, including the short links the Share button copies. Stories, lives, private accounts and TikTok photo posts can't be used.

Are replies counted?

Not by default, so a reply to a friend isn't an entry. Turn on Include replies if your rules count them.

How long does a draw take?

Small posts are usually done within a minute. Posts with thousands of comments can take a few minutes. Keep the tab open while it reads.

Plans and payment

Is Best Comment Picker free?

Yes, for posts up to 300 comments: you get 1 free draw a day with no account and no sign-up. Bigger posts need a paid plan: Plus ($12 a month) reads posts up to 3,000 comments with 3 draws a week, and Pro ($39 a month) reads posts up to 15,000 comments with 7 draws a week.

Is there a free comment picker with no limit?

Reading comments costs every picker money, so free plans always have a limit somewhere: on comments, on draws or on features. Ours is free for posts up to 300 comments with 1 draw a day, no account, and every feature included: several winners, backups, entry rules, the wheel, the result page and the winner video. Bigger posts need Plus or Pro.

What if a draw fails?

A draw that fails or matches no entries doesn't count against your plan. If a paid draw failed or read too few comments, write to us for a full refund.

Can I cancel anytime?

Yes, from your account page. You keep your plan until the end of the period you paid for.

Trust and privacy

Can my followers check the result?

Yes. Every draw gets a public result page with the winners, backups, your rules and the time of the draw. Post the link in your story or caption so anyone can check it.

What do you keep?

For each draw we keep the result page: the winners and backups with their comments, your rules, the counts and the time. The other comments aren't saved in our database. We never ask for your social media passwords.

Is it affiliated with Instagram or TikTok?

No. Best Comment Picker is an independent tool and isn't affiliated with, endorsed or sponsored by Instagram, Meta or TikTok.

Still have a question? Write to us and a person will answer. Send us a message