A commentpicker.com alternative with no Instagram login
Best Comment Picker Team · Facts checked October 4, 2026
commentpicker.com's free Instagram picker reads only 100 comments and needs you to log in with an Instagram business or creator account. Best Comment Picker needs neither: paste the link to any public Instagram post, reel or TikTok video and draw for free on posts up to 300 comments, with up to 10 winners, entry rules and a public result page, with no account at all.
| Best Comment Picker | commentpicker.com | |
|---|---|---|
| Free plan | Yes, 1 draw a day | Yes, with ads |
| Free comment limit per post | Up to 300 | 100 on Instagram, 30 on TikTok |
| Account or login needed | No account, no Instagram or TikTok login | Instagram or Facebook login, business or creator accounts only |
| TikTok giveaways | Yes | Yes |
| Winners per draw | Up to 10, plus 5 backups | 1 free, up to 10 on Premium |
| Entry rules (tags, hashtag, duplicates) | Yes, on every plan | Duplicate filter free; @mention filter on Premium |
| Winner video | Yes, on every plan | Yes, an animated announcement video |
| Public result page | Yes, on every plan | Yes |
| Paid plans from | $12/month (3,000 comments a post, 3 draws a week) | $9.99/month or $95.91/year (Premium) |
commentpicker.com details from its own website on October 4, 2026. Plans change: check its site before a big giveaway.
What is commentpicker.com?
commentpicker.com is a large set of free giveaway tools: comment pickers for Instagram, TikTok and other platforms, plus random name pickers and wheels.
Its Instagram picker works through Meta's official API, so you log in with Instagram, or with Facebook as an admin of the linked Page, and only business and creator accounts are supported. The free version reads up to 100 comments from one post, picks one winner and shows ads; on TikTok it reads up to 30 comments with no login. Premium, billed through Patreon at $9.99 a month or $95.91 a year, removes the Instagram comment limit, picks up to 10 winners, adds the @mention filter and several posts per draw, and removes the ads.
Where Best Comment Picker is different
No login, and personal accounts work
Paste the link to a public post and draw. There's no Instagram, Facebook or TikTok login, so it works the same for personal, creator and business accounts, and you never hand over account access.
More comments and winners for free
The free plan reads posts up to 300 comments on Instagram and TikTok alike, and every draw can have up to 10 winners and 5 backups. commentpicker.com's free plan reads 100 Instagram comments (30 on TikTok) and picks one winner.
Every rule on the free plan
Friends tagged, a required word or hashtag, one entry per account, replies and accounts to leave out all work on the free plan. On commentpicker.com the @mention filter is Premium only.
When commentpicker.com is the better pick
- Your posts have many thousands of comments and you draw often: Premium has no Instagram comment limit for $9.99 a month, while our plans cap comments per post.
- You need a picker for another platform we don't cover, or random name pickers and wheels for your own lists.
- You'd rather the draw ran through your own Instagram login and Meta's official API.
Questions
Is Best Comment Picker free?
Yes, for posts up to 300 comments: 1 draw a day with no account and every feature included. Plus ($12 a month) reads posts up to 3,000 comments with 3 draws a week, and Pro ($39 a month) reads posts up to 15,000 comments with 7 draws a week.
Do I need to log in with Instagram or TikTok?
No. Paste the link to a public Instagram post or reel, or a TikTok video. Best Comment Picker reads the public comments and never asks for your Instagram or TikTok password.
Why does commentpicker.com ask for an Instagram business account?
Its Instagram picker reads comments through Meta's official API, which works only with business and creator accounts you log in with. Best Comment Picker reads the public comments of a public post, so no login is needed and the account type doesn't matter.
Other comparisons
- A Pickfetti alternative that also does TikTok
- An AppSorteos alternative with every rule on the free plan
- A free Simpliers alternative for Instagram and TikTok
- A Wask comment picker alternative with proof built in
- A free Easypromos alternative for comment giveaways
- A Woobox comment picker alternative with no Facebook login