How to pick an Instagram giveaway winner
Best Comment Picker Team · Updated October 10, 2026
To pick an Instagram giveaway winner, copy the link of your giveaway post, paste it into a comment picker, set the same entry rules you announced (one entry per account, friends tagged, a required hashtag), then draw at random. Use a picker that gives you a result page, so your followers can check the draw was fair.
Before you draw: check your rules
Your caption is a promise. Before drawing, reread it and write down every entry rule you announced, because the draw must apply exactly those rules, no more and no less.
- Did you ask people to tag friends? How many?
- Did you require a word or hashtag in the comment?
- Does each account get one entry, or one entry per comment?
- Do replies to other comments count?
- Who is excluded (your team, partners, your own account)?
Step 1: copy the post link
In the Instagram app, open the post or reel, tap the share icon, then Copy link. On a computer, copy the address from the browser bar. The post must be public: a picker can't read comments on a private account.
Step 2: paste it and check the count
Paste the link into Best Comment Picker and press Check post. You'll see the number of comments and whether the free plan covers it (up to 300 comments), or which plan does.
Step 3: set the same rules you announced
Set the number of winners and backup winners, then the entry rules. Backups matter: if a winner doesn't answer, you contact the next backup instead of drawing again, which is fairer and easier to explain.
- Friends tagged: counts different accounts tagged with @, not the same friend twice
- Must include: a word or #hashtag, in any case
- One entry per account: several comments from one account count once
- Leave out accounts: your team or partners (the post's own account is always left out)
Step 4: draw, record and announce
Choose a countdown or wheel reveal if you want to screen-record the moment, then draw. The winners are picked with cryptographic random numbers on the server. Share the result page, which shows the winners, your rules and the time of the draw, then contact the winner by direct message and announce them publicly.
Mistakes that make a giveaway look rigged
- Changing the rules after the giveaway ends
- Drawing again because you didn't like the first winner
- Picking by hand or scrolling to a random comment
- Letting a friend, employee or your own account win
- Announcing a winner without showing how they were picked
Questions
Can I pick an Instagram winner without an app?
Yes. Best Comment Picker runs in the browser: paste the post link, no app to install and no Instagram login needed.
How do I pick a winner from a reel?
The same way as a post: copy the reel's link from Share, paste it and draw. Reels and carousels work like any public post.
Is picking a random comment fair if someone commented many times?
Only if your rules say each comment is an entry. Most giveaways give one entry per account, so keep One entry per account on.